
I hadn't seen my archaeologically-inclined pal Kristin for some time. There's a good excuse. She's been on a dig in Yemen uncovering ancient relics - no small feat when you're under local tribesman sniper fire.
And to think, she even took time out to pick me up a few foodie trinkets: a jar of deep, dark brown summer honey, a stash of Iranian saffron, and authentic Yemen coffee laced with cardamom. One whiff of the coffee and I was hooked. Caffeinated crack. Later today I'll purchase a proper ibrik to whip up some Yemenite brew. I may also be forced to use a portion for truly nefarious purposes: coffee gelato.
Evil. Pure evil.
With my foodie gifts surrounding me, I knew the pressure was "on" for our restaurant pick that evening, Dona (pictured above). It had garnered glowing reviews, so we were hopeful as we headed to our table. And, between the friendly, professional service we encountered, the gorgeous bottle of Rioja we began to sip, and the irresistable dinner menu we began to scan, we were becoming very hopeful.
And so, we ordered...me the regular tasting menu and Kristin the lobster tasting...
My Kumomoto Oyster Crudo with pink grapefruit and salty ginger was a briny, sweet-sour revelation. That dish was followed by Grilled Sardines served with a confetti of blistered red and yellow peppers, drizzled with a warm anchovy vinaigrette. It was like the Mediterranean was giving me a salty, sea kiss - with tongue.
Kristin was equally dazzled by her parade of courses - including an oversized Lobster Ravioli stuffed with tail meat and an oozing, rich egg yolk, topped with glorious black pearls of caviar.
My pasta selecion of Chiattara tossed in a Pastichio-inspired "bolognese" of rich lamb, eggplant, tomatoes and hints of cinnamon with a shower of shaved white Mezithra cheese, was rustic and luscious all at once.
Only my entree of Grilled Loin of Pork "Portafogli" with shaved fennel and salty orange rind preserve topped with pork belly and saffron couscous was a bit of a disappointment. Kristin on the other hand thought it was a brilliant combination, clearly lusting after my plate. But she wasn't about to make a switch with a mound of sweet Lobster Tails cooked in a lemony Avgolemono set in front of her.
As we nibbled on a White Chocolage Semifreddo and sipped heady Macchiatos we realized that Dona was a culinary winner. It was service winner.
Yet, we had no urge to return.
What? Why?
Quite simply, it wasn't a fit. Between its decidedly Midtown East address, over-dressed and overly-botoxed clientele and its overly-pimped decor complete with wall-to-wall zebra carpeting - reminiscent of Carmela Soprano's version of "classy" - we just couldn't take pleasure in Dona's ambience. I'll say it again - It wasn't a fit.
It seems that both Kristin and I like our palates to take Mr. Toad's Wild Ride - but we want the rest of us to enjoy the ride too.
So, later today my ibrik will be purchased - and I'll aim for a wild ride once again - but with the rest of me along for good measure.